A-Rod and Four Homer Games
What Alex Rodriguez is doing in New York is beyond description. The Yankees have now played 16 games, which is always a good benchmark because you can multiply the numbers by 10 to project what the season might look like.
At this pace, Alex Rodriguez will hit .379 with 120 homers, 310 RBIs and 200 runs scored.
Of course, if we're projecting things out, then Royals catcher John Buck will hit .429 with 30 homers (and 40 RBIs!) in 280 at-bats.
Two things about A-Rod's hot start: One, it allows us to look back at the absolutely ridiculous start of Mike Schmidt in 1976. Through 16 games that year, Schmidt was hitting .299 with 12 homers, 21 RBIs and 17 runs scored. I recall that start seemed even more amazing than A-Rod's because we had not been jaded by 73 home run seasons -- Schmidt had led the National League with 38 homers in 1975 (Ron Cey had finished fifth in the league with 25 homers).
The big day in Schmidt's start was his four homer game against the Cubs on April 17. There are all sorts of fun facts about that day; my favorite is that Schmidt hit two homers off of starter Rick Reuschel and hit one homer off his brother Paul Reuschel (the other homer was off of Mike Garman). I've seen it written in several places that Dave Kingman hit three homers that day, but that isn't true -- he wasn't in that game. He played for the Mets in '76. Rick Monday did hit two homers. Steve Carlton had the second-worst outing of his Major League career -- 1 2/3 innings, 7 runs. The Phillies won 18-16, the key being Schmidt's 10th inning homer off P-Rush.
What the heck, let's look at all the four-homer games since 1900:
Four homer games
Lou Gehrig, June 3, 1931 at Philadelphia A's
Gehrig hit a fifth ball to the warning track. ... Tony Lazzeri hit for the cycle that SAME GAME; you want to talk about a letdown. Imagine: You hit for the cycle, you go to the bar after the game, wait for someone to buy you a drink and everybody's toasting bleepin' Lou Gehrig. ... Yankees beat the A's 20-13.
Chuck Klein, July 10, 1936 at Pittsburgh
Hit his fourth homer in the 10th inning to give his Phillies a rare victory ... Game was played at Forbes Field in Pittsburgh and not at Philly's famed home run band box, the Baker Bowl ... OK, we have to take a moment to break down just how bad a pitcher's park the Baker Bowl was. In 1917, the Phillies traded Pete Alexander to the Cubs. Look at the Phillies ERAs after that.
1918: 3.15 (Last in the NL)
1919: 4.14 (Last)
1920: 3.63 (Last)
1921: 4.48 (Last)
1922: 4.64 (Last)
1923: 5.34 (Last)
1924: 4.87 (Last)
1925: 5.02 (Last)
1926: 5.03 (Last)
1927: 5.36 (Last)
1928: 5.57 (Last)
1929: 6.13 (Last)
1930: 6.71 (Last -- one and a half runs worse than anyone)
1931: 4.58 (Last)
1932: 4.47 (Last)
1933: 4.34 (Last)
1934: 4.76 (Last)
1935: 4.76 (Seventh out of eight!)
1936: 4.64 (Last)
1937: 5.25 (Last)
The next year they moved to Shibe Park. I imagine there has never been a stretch of bad pitching like that. Most years, they also gave up the most home runs in the league. That park was a joke. ... Back to Chuck Klein. The Phillies lost 100 games again that year; In his amazing career, Klein played on EIGHT Phillies teams that lost 100 games or more. Bill James once put together an all-star team of players from teams that lost 100. Klein's 1930 season -- .386, 40, 170 -- hits cleanup.
Pat Seerey, July 18, 1948 at Philadelphia A's
Second time someone hit four homers happened at Shibe Park ... This was a brilliant moment in an otherwise undistinguished career. It's tough to say whether Seery or Hard Hittin' Mark Whiten is the better player. They both had 108 ERA+ for their careers. ... Seerey was a stocky little guy from Oklahoma who hit .224 in his career and led the league in strikeouts five times. But he could run into a ball; he hit 26 homers in 404 at-bats in 1946 ... The White Sox had traded for him just six weeks earlier (by coincidence, the Phillies had traded for Klein six weeks before his four-homer game).
Gil Hodges, August 31, 1950 vs. Boston Braves
Also had a single in the game, which the Dodgers won 19-3 ... He hit his first homer off of Warren Spahn ... That's really all I have to say about this game except that Hodges should be the first recipient of the "Buck O'Neil Award" which the Hall of Fame should give for lifetime achievement in baseball. Hodges was a great player, he was a beloved player, and he was the manager of the 1969 Mets. I think he would be a great choice.
Joe Adcock, July 31, 1954 at Brooklyn Dodgers
Second time someone hit four homers at Ebbetts Field ... Adcock also hit a double off the top of the wall, which allowed him to break Hodges record for total bases in a game ... Bill James says Adcock had more homers taken away by his ballpark than any player in baseball history. County Stadium in Milwaukee was a brutal hitter's park. It was not as extreme as the Baker Bowl, of course, but from 1953 when it opened until 1960, the Braves finished first or second in league ERA six times ... Of course, that was also the park where Hank Aaron spent the majority of his career. In 1957, the first year where splits are available, an injured Adcock hit 12 homers, nine of them on the road. Aaron hit 44 homers, 26 of them on the road.
Rocky Colavito, June 10, 1959 at Baltimore
The first thing I can remember my father saying to me at a ballgame is: "There's Rocky Colavito. He once hit four home runs in a game." ... Rocky hit the first homer off of Baltimore starter Jerry Walker, the next two off reliever Arnie Portocarrero and the last in the ninth inning off of lovable Ernie Johnson, who became the voice of the Atlanta Braves on WTBS ... Ernie Johnson's middle name is "Thorwald." Sorry, thought you needed to know ... Colavito is the first guy to hit his four homers in four official at-bats. He walked in the first inning.
Willie Mays, April 30, 1961 at Milwaukee
We just told you how ridiculously hard it was to hit at Milwaukee County Stadium so in many ways this is the most impressive performance. ... It was a homer frenzy that day. The wind must have been blowing out and hard. Mays hit two homers off of Lew Burdette, one off of Seth Morehead (that one went out of County Stadium) and one off Don McMahon. But that wasn't all. Hank Aaron hit two homers that day. Jose Pagan, who would hit five homers all season, hit two homers that day. Orlando Cepeda homered and so did Felipe Alou. ... Billy Loes threw a complete game for the Giants. He's the Zelig of four-homer games. He was with Baltimore when Colavito hit his four homers, he was with Brooklyn when Joe Adcock hit his four homers and he may have been with the Dodgers when Gil Hodges hit his four homers -- he was called up that year.
Mike Schmidt, April 17, 1976 at Chicago Cubs
Bob Horner, July 6, 1986 vs. Montreal
The Braves actually lost this game 11-8. In fact, I remember well the last homer. It was with two outs, bottom of the ninth, nobody on, the Braves down four runs. ... That was typical Braves of the 1980s -- it was sometime that decade that the Atlanta Constitution decided to run a contest where they had people come up with marketing slogans for the Braves. I only remember one: "Braves baseball: Better than getting hit in the head with a hammer ... unless it's a doubleheader." ... Horner had a beautiful compact swing -- the swing looked a lot like Mike Schmidt's. He hit the first three homers off of Andy McGaffigan and the last off of closer Jeff Reardon (who got one of the all-time cheapo saves in history -- came in the eighth with his team up four runs and one man on. And he gave up Bob Horner's fourth homer. That's a save?). ... Horner only hit 13 more homers in the Major Leagues after this. He did hit some in Japan.
Hard-Hittin' Mark Whiten, Sept. 7, 1993 at Cincinnati
I will always remember this day because Mark Tomasik, a good friend and old boss of mine -- ALSO A HUGE Cardinals fan -- was not at the game. I cannot even begin to explain how big a Cardinals fan Mark is. I actually have a couple of friends who are pretty psychotic Cards fans -- I might want to reevaluate my life a bit. Anyway, what a lot of people forget about this game (if they actually ever knew it) is Whiten hit his four homers in the second game of a doubleheader. Mark lived in Cincinnati, so of course he went out to the stadium. It was a dream day for him -- a Cardinals doubleheader. In the first game, the Cardinals blew a lead in the ninth (Reggie Sanders hit a two-run triple) and lost 14-13. Mark was so enraged he left the stadium, went home, and missed Whiten's four-home run game.
Whiten had 12 RBIs that day ... He hit the first off of Larry Luebbers, two off of Mike Anderson and the last off Rob Dibble. That last one was particularly impressive -- Dibble had his nasty stuff that day. He struck out the side looking in the ninth. ... Whiten had not hit a home run in almost a month leading into that game. A week later, though, he had a two-homer game against Montreal.
Mike Cameron, May 2, 2002 at Chicago White Sox
Cameron and Bret Boone both hit two home runs in the first inning that day. ... Cameron hit his first homer off of John Rauch and the last three off of Jim Parque. He actually had two chances to hit his fifth homer. The first chance he got plunked (naturally). The second he hit a long fly ball to right.
Shawn Green, May 23, 2002 at Milwaukee
This was the official date for me when the home run thing in baseball went out of control. Yes, Barry Bonds had hit 73 homers the year before (and Mark McGwire had hit 70, and Sosa had broken Maris' mark three times and so on). But I just remember that month -- when two guys (and not just any two guys -- Mike Cameron and Shawn Green!) hit four homers in a game -- and thinking, "OK, enough already." ... Green had six hits in the game ... Through 2002, Green had 24 multi-homer games in six seasons. Four per year -- that seems amazing to me. Heck, George Brett had 17 multi-homer games in his CAREER. Since 2002, Green has had six multi-homer games, which isn't terrible. But it isn't superhuman.
Carlos Delgado, Sept. 26, 2003 vs. Tampa Bay
Like Colavito, he hit his four homers in four official at-bats. ... His last homer actually mattered; the Blue Jays were trailing 8-7 in the ninth when he banged a lead-off homer to tie the score. The Blue Jays scored two more and won the game 10-8.
OK, we kind of got off-track there. We were talking about A-Rod, and his amazing start. Allard Baird tells a great story about when he was a scout for the Royals -- his responsibility was Florida. So he went to Westminster Christian in Miami to scout A-Rod (and also Doug Mientkiewicz, who was on that team).
You know, every scout I've ever known has this dream that one day he will come across the perfect player (in the dream, of course, he DISCOVERS the perfect player, which isn't easy to do these days). Allard was still a pretty young scout then -- barely 30 -- and so he really did not have much to base his thoughts on. But he saw this kid who could do everything. He could run. He hit. He hit with easy power. He had the best infield arm Allard had ever seen. He played with that sort of joy you wish you could inject in every baseball prospect.
Allard was absolutely blown away. It was no secret that A-Rod was a great prospect, of course, but Allard had literally seen nothing like it. He wrote a report so glowing (he wrote that A-Rod had Major League All-Star tools RIGHT THEN, as a junior in high school) that he was actually shaking when he faxed it in.
As it turned out, it didn't matter -- the Royals never had a chance at A-Rod who went (obviously) with the first overall pick in the draft. The Royals did get Jeff Granger in that draft, though to be fair that wasn't Allard's guy. Allard's guy was taken in the first round the year before, a speedy outfielder named Johnny Damon. There's a story behind that too, but we'll save it for another blog.